Japan Geoscience Union Meeting 2018

Session information

[EE] Oral

S (Solid Earth Sciences) » S-IT Science of the Earth's Interior & Tectonophysics

[S-IT21] Do plumes exist?

Sun. May 20, 2018 1:45 PM - 3:15 PM 301A (3F International Conference Hall, Makuhari Messe)

convener:Hidehisa Mashima(Center for Obsidian and Lithic Studies, Meiji University), Gillian R Foulger (Durham University), Dapeng Zhao(東北大学大学院理学研究科附属地震・噴火予知研究観測センター), Chairperson:Mashima Hidehisa

The debate regarding whether anomalous volcanic areas on Earth's surface are fed by deep-mantle plumes is widely considered to be the most significant debate currently ongoing in Earth science. Not only does the debate touch on a fundamental aspect of how Earth works dynamically, but the subject is extraordinarily cross-disciplinary to an extent that probably few scientists fully realize. Sub-disciplines that can contribute to efforts to resolve the debate include sedimentology, palaeontology, tectonophysics, geochronology, volcanology, petrology, geochemistry, geothermal research, seismology, geodesy, electromagnetics and many others.

In addition to the disciplines of Earth science, the plume debate provides a remarkable and thought-provoking subject for scientific philosophy and reflections on correct scientific methodology: (1) What exactly is a plume? People often change their definition of a plume a posteriori in order to fit their observations. (2) How can the plume- or the plate hypothesis be falsified? (3) Do Earth scientists tend to present only one possible interpretation of their data, or do papers reflect all possible interpretations? Unfortunately, the former is often the case. (4) Are published interpretations consistent with other data from the subject field area? Often they are not, and the inconsistencies are not sufficiently highlighted nor discussed. These issues are particularly useful for inducting students into correct scientific working. In summary, the debate provides enormously fertile ground for new, fundamental questions and cross-disciplinary research.

This session welcomes studies of melting anomalies on Earth from the point of view of any sub-discipline. We also welcomes studies of geological phenomena which are attributed to mantle plumes, such as back-arc extension, plate motion, sedimentary basin formation and lithospheric uplift, and any other work that bears on this fascinating and challenging geological debate.

1:45 PM - 2:15 PM

*Gillian R Foulger1, Tony Doré2, Dieter Franke3, Laurent Geoffroy4, Laurent Gernigon5, Malcolm Hole6, Armann Hoskuldsson7, Bruce Julian1, Nick Kusznir8, Fernando Martinez9, James Natland10, Alex Peace11, Kenni Petersen12, Christian Schiffer1, Randell Stephenson6, Martyn Stoker13 (1.Durham University, 2.Statoil (UK) Ltd, 3.Bundesanstalt für Geowissenschaften und Rohstoffe, 4.Laboratoire "Géosciences Océan", 5.Geological Survey of Norway (NGU), 6.School of Geosciences, Univ. Aberdeen, 7.Science Institute, Univ. Iceland, 8.School of Environmental Sciences, Univ. Liverpool, 9.School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology, Univ. Hawaii at Manoa, 10.Univ. Miami, 11.Dept. Earth Sciences, Memorial Univ. Newfoundland, 12.Dept. Geoscience, Aarhus University, 13.Australian School of Petroleum, Univ. Adelaide)



Abstract password authentication.
Password is required to view the abstract. Please enter a password to authenticate.


Please log in with your participant account.
» Participant Log In